Español jurídico: denuncia; querella

In Spain, a denuncia is the report of a crime to the police, a prosecutor or a judge. The alleged offense is then investigated and, if found to have merit, prosecuted. But once a denuncia is made, it is out of the hands of the informant who reported the crime. In contrast, in a querella, the person reporting the crime becomes a party to the proceedings. This is often the public prosecutor, in which case this is known as a querella del Ministerio Fiscal (“criminal complaint filed by the Public Prosecution Service”). But in contrast to Anglo-American criminal procedure, in Spain the victim, or at times even an ordinary citizen may report a crime and indicate that he intends to enter an appearance as a party to the criminal proceedings, and his lawyer then usually prosecutes the case alongside the public prosecutor (fiscal).

In that regard, in addition to the powers of the public prosecutor to prosecute criminal offenses on behalf of the state, in Spain the victim or any other private citizen may enter an appearance (personarse) in criminal proceedings in what amounts to a “private prosecution” that is practically unknown or in disuse in Anglo-American jurisdictions. In this context “acusación (or) acusador particular” generally denotes the victim of a crime (or his representative) who files a private criminal complaint, entering an appearance in a criminal proceeding as a private prosecutor. Moreover, persons other than the victim may also enter an appearance in criminal proceedings as private prosecutors. In that regard acusación (or) acusador popular denotes a private citizen who files a querella and posts a bond (fianza) in order to be admitted as a party to the prosecution of a criminal case. And acusación (or) acusador privado refers to an individual seeking redress for a private offense (delito privado) that may only be prosecuted by the victim and in which the public prosecutor does not intervene.

In summary, denuncia is a “crime report” or the “report of a crime to the police (or other authority),” while in the cases initiated by private individuals querella may perhaps be described as a “private criminal prosecution.” For more on this peculiar Spanish system of allowing private individuals to participate as parties to criminal prosecutions see:

Julio Pérez Gil. “Private Interests Seeking Punishment: Prosecution Brought by Private Individuals and Groups in Spain.” Law & Policy, Volume 25 Issue 2 (April, 2003), pp. 151-172.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s